Questions about full frame and insert window replacement come up all the time when we’re talking to homeowners in Kansas City. Homeowners often want to know if a full tear replacement is the right choice or if a replacement window will do the job. It’s an important decision that can affect the look, feel, and performance of your home for years to come.

Let’s walk through what each option involves, its advantages and drawbacks, and how to decide what’s best for your home.

What is Full Frame and Insert Window Replacement?

Full Frame Replacement (Full Tear)

A full frame replacement, often called a full tear, involves removing the entire window frame down to the drywall. We then install a new window using nail fins to secure it to the home’s framing. This process also includes replacing the interior trim and, in some cases, patching drywall to create a seamless and finished appearance.

Insert (Pocket) Replacement

An insert window replacement involves placing a new window that’s slightly smaller into the existing frame. We keep the original frame intact and fit the new window snugly inside it.

The Pros and Cons of Full Frame Replacement

Pros of Full Frame Replacement

• Maximizes Glass Space
  Full frame replacement can give you a little more glass, which is great for extra light and views.
• Addresses Wood Rot Thoroughly
  It allows us to get rid of all wood rot, inside and out, by exposing the full structure.

Cons of Full Frame Replacement

• Higher Cost
  This option adds about $400 per window, which can add up to $8,000 to $10,000 on a full-home project.
• Loss of Original Trim
  For homes with beautiful, high-quality wood trim, like many older homes in our area, it’s tough to find matching materials today. In my own Fairway home, I wouldn’t dream of losing that original trim and character.

The Pros and Cons of Insert Window Replacement

Pros of Insert Replacement

• Preserves Your Home’s Charm
  Insert window replacement keeps your existing interior trim and casing in place. If you have beautiful woodwork from the 1940s or 1950s, this is often the best way to maintain that original charm.
• Lower Cost
  Without the need to replace interior trim and fix drywall, you save money and avoid disrupting your home’s design.

Cons of Insert Replacement

• Less Glass Space
  You might lose about half an inch of glass space compared to a full-frame installation.
• Wood Rot Considerations
  Insert replacement doesn’t expose the entire window frame, but we always make sure to repair any visible wood rot on both the interior and exterior.

How We Handle Wood Rot and Exterior Trim

Repairing Visible Wood Rot

We take wood rot seriously, no matter what replacement option you choose. Before we install your new windows, we carefully repair any wood rot that’s visible on the interior and exterior frames. We charge for this extra work, but it gives you peace of mind knowing the problem is handled.

Upgrading Exterior Trim

Instead of just wrapping the exterior in aluminum (which can look cheap and hide problems), we often recommend installing all-new exterior trim or brick mold. This allows us to remove more siding on the outside and thoroughly inspect for hidden rot. It’s an extra step that ensures long-term performance and enhances the look of your home.

Choosing the Right Option for Your Home

For many homeowners in older neighborhoods like Fairway or Mission Hills, full frame and insert window replacement is about preserving the character of the home. Older homes have beautiful trim and molding that can’t be matched with today’s materials. Replacing those original features with cheaper trim can take away from the home’s charm and style.

For newer homes, the decision often comes down to cost and the amount of glass space you’d like to gain. If your existing trim is basic and you want to eliminate wood rot entirely, a full frame replacement may be the best option.

Key Takeaways

• Full frame replacement removes everything and installs new windows with nail fins. It’s best for maximizing glass and eliminating rot, but it costs more and can’t match historic trim.
• Insert window replacement fits new windows into the existing frame, saving your original trim and costing less.
• We always check and repair visible wood rot in either scenario.
• Updating exterior trim instead of using aluminum wrapping is a smart move to ensure long-term durability and a quality look.

Ready to Upgrade Your Windows?

At Fairway Exteriors, we understand how important it is to protect your home’s style and value. We’ll help you decide whether full frame and insert window replacement is the right choice for your specific project. Our team will guide you through each step and ensure you’re happy with the result.

Contact us today for a consultation, and let’s talk about what will work best for your home!