Why James Hardie vs Kansas City Vinyl Siding?

vinyl siding vs hardie siding kansas city

Table of Contents

If you are looking at Kansas City vinyl siding for your new siding, you may want to do some research first. Vinyl siding is a popular type of siding that does have its pros and cons. But for longevity, durability, and versatility, fiber cement siding from James Hardie can be a better option. Over the past year vinyl has taken 5 price increases and Hardie has gone up only once. Now the price is very competitive between the 2 products. Besides the lower cost, vinyl doesn’t always save you money if you have to maintain or replace it.

Why James Hardie vs Kansas City Vinyl Siding?

There is no perfect solution when it comes to siding. More and more people are turning to fiber cement siding over other types. Vinyl is made of plastic and fiber cement contains Portland cement, sand, water, and cellulose fibers.


Kansas City vinyl siding is expensive, experiencing long lead times, but is easy to install. But it doesn’t have the strength or the durability of other materials, in particular, fiber cement.

While both are durable, vinyl is more susceptible to damage. If hit with the car, the lawnmower, or even just kids playing nearby, it can become damaged with dents, tears, or cracks.

Heat and Cold Resistant

While Hardie siding can withstand a house fire and come out mostly unscathed, just the sun or a BBQ can damage your Kansas City vinyl siding. Once the vinyl is warped, the panel needs to be replaced.

The Hardie siding can handle any type of severe weather and is mostly unaffected by the heat or the cold. Vinyl has been known to crack in freezing temperatures.

However, the Hardie siding is made to suit various regions around the country. Something made for cold dry weather would not be sold in an area with high humidity.


Both of these siding materials are low maintenance. But, you can paint your fiber cement siding if you want to, but you can’t paint vinyl. The vinyl will fade in the sun, which will make the color of your home uneven. The fiber cement won’t fade.

Hardie fiber cement siding can be rinsed off with the garden hose very easily. It maintains its color and is guaranteed for 30 years. Their unique color process will hold the color for many years.

Looks Better

Hardie fiber can be made to represent almost any other type of material. Where are vinyl only looks like plastic and its curb appeal decreases every day after it is installed. The clear winner is Hardie fiber cement. They can construct their siding to mimic almost any type of wood, stone, or brick.

It also stays looking that way for a much longer time. With vinyl, artistic liberties are definitely limited. The density of the Hardie siding provides a much more realistic appearance.


Your Kansas City vinyl siding might be the more affordable option. But the Hardie siding is still less expensive than many other types of materials. And because it can be made to look like cedar, you get the look without the cost or the maintenance.

The vinyl siding is made to order and easier to install. But, it doesn’t last as long and vinyl often requires far more work and repairs over the years.

James Hardie vs Kansas City Vinyl Siding

If you need more information or a free consultation, please contact us here at Fairway Exteriors. New siding is an investment in your home and you should consider the options very carefully.

Hardie siding is made to last for many years, improves the value of your home, and looks great for many years. Our number one rated Kansas City James Hardie Siding contractors will help you transform your home’s exteriors to perfection.

Scott Neidow

Scott Neidow


Limited Time Offer

Get 50% Off

Your James Hardie
Siding Material