Homeowners often compare composite siding and fiber cement to see which lasts longer and holds up better in Kansas City’s changing weather. Each has its own makeup, look, and level of care needed. The real difference comes down to how they handle heat, cold, and moisture over the years.
This guide explains what sets the two materials apart in cost, upkeep, and performance. It also covers why fiber cement siding is often the stronger, longer-lasting choice for local homes.
Quick Answer for KC Homeowners
- Most KC homes get the best mix of strength, fire safety, and style from fiber cement, especially Hardie Plank.
- Composite works for low-paint goals but can cost more and show different wear in the sun and heat.
When to choose fiber cement: strong fire rating, stable in freeze and wind, a wide style range.
When to choose composite: want factory color that needs little upkeep, simple trim lines.
Composite Siding and Fiber Cement: Side by Side
| Feature | Fiber Cement (Hardie Plank) | Composite Siding (Everlast) |
| Material Makeup | Made from cement, sand, and cellulose fibers | Varies by brand; Everlast uses PVC-based composite |
| Typical Brands | Hardie Plank | Everlast |
| Warranty | Long-term, backed by the manufacturer and installer | Strong coverage; terms vary by brand |
| Hail & Wind Resistance | Holds shape and resists impact well | Performs well but can flex under heavy impact |
| Fire Rating | Noncombustible (Class A) | Typically Class B or lower; not fully fireproof |
| Moisture & Fade Resistance | Excellent moisture defense; color holds with ColorPlus® finish | Good moisture resistance; fade resistance depends on formulation |
| Maintenance | Simple cleaning and occasional caulking | Minimal upkeep; no repainting needed |
| Installed Cost Range | Moderate to high, depends on trim and detail | Moderate to high, similar range |
| ROI (Resale Value) | High resale returns in national reports | Moderate resale appeal |
| Installation Complexity | Requires precise flashing and fastening | Easier cuts; still needs skilled labor |
Key Takeaway: Fiber cement (Hardie Plank) wins for most Kansas City homes thanks to its proven strength in freeze-thaw cycles, high wind resistance, and fire safety.
What Each Material Is
Fiber Cement Siding (Hardie Plank)
This is a dense, stable board. It handles heat and cold, holds paint or ColorPlus® finishes, and resists fire and pests.
Composite Siding
“Composite” covers PVC or polymer blends. Everlast is a PVC-based composite. It is not the same as engineered wood and has different trim and joint rules.
Performance in Kansas City Weather
Moisture, Freeze-Thaw, and Humidity
Good joints, caulk, and flashing are vital. We set clear gaps, seal ends, and manage water so walls dry fast.
Hail and Wind Ratings
Storms push water and grit. Fiber cement keeps its shape and takes hits well when fastened right.
Fire Resistance and Insurance
Fiber cement is noncombustible. That can help with safety rules where homes sit close.
Pro Tip: Ask for a wall mockup that shows housewrap, flashing, and joint layout before you sign.
Durability and Longevity
Wear Patterns After 5–10 Years
Watch for edge wear, seam gaps, chalking, and color fade. Correct installation and cleaning slow these down.
Warranty Reality Check
Read what voids a claim. Workmanship matters as much as the product. Local support is your backup.
Appearance and Design Flexibility
Profiles, Textures, and Color Systems
You can choose lap, panel, shake, and trim looks. Hardie ColorPlus® stays even and neat. Composite color is baked in and consistent.
Matching KC Styles
We match Tudor, Colonial, mid-century, and modern builds. See our gallery and book a design consult.
Cost, Maintenance, and Total Cost of Ownership
Installed Cost Ranges in KC
Both systems can price close. Trim, story height, and access affect totals more than the board alone.
Maintenance Over 15–20 Years
Plan light washing, targeted recaulk, and paint cycles for fiber cement. Composite leans on wash-only care.
Resale Value and Appraisal Notes
Fiber cement often scores well with buyers due to fire safety and brand trust.
Ready for advice you can trust? Get a free design consult with Fairway Exteriors.
Installation Differences That Matter
Substrate Prep, Flashing, and Water Management
We level, wrap, flash, and vent so water moves out, not in. That keeps walls dry.
Fasteners, Joints, and Trim
We use rated fasteners, proper joint covers, and full trim systems for clean lines.
Common Mistakes We Prevent
Tight joints, missed flashing, and poor caulk fail fast. Our lifetime workmanship warranty backs our work.
Pro Tip: Ask to see past KC jobs with the same profile and trim you want.
Brand Showdown: Everlast vs Hardie Plank
Hardie Plank Fiber Cement
Pros: fire safety, storm stability, broad styles. Watch-outs: follow paint and caulk rules. Best for most KC homes.
Everlast Composite
Pros: low repaint needs, crisp seams. Watch-outs: trim details differ. Best for simple lines and fast color.
Which One Wins By Scenario
Forever home, highest fire rating, historic look: fiber cement. Lake humidity or very low paint goals: composite can fit.
Which Is Best for Your Home
Set your goal first. If you want the safest and most stable wall in KC, composite siding and fiber cement both work, but fiber cement often fits best. For the lowest repaint plan, composite can be a fit. We will show you both.
Why Kansas City Chooses Fairway Exteriors
We bring deep Hardie expertise, design-first planning, and clean job sites you can trust. See our reviews and awards.
FAQs
Is composite the same as engineered wood? No.
Do I need housewrap? Yes, with both systems.
Will fiber cement crack in winter? Not when installed right.
How often do I repaint ColorPlus®? Much longer cycles than field paint.
Can I mix with stone or stucco? Yes, with proper trim.
Get a Precise Recommendation
Let us review your home in Overland Park, Olathe, Leawood, Prairie Village, Shawnee, Lenexa, Lee’s Summit, Mission Hills, or Fairway. Schedule your free consult today.
